Cowboys drafting a tight end in round 1 would be insanity

17
Multiple Reports Link Dallas Cowboys to round one Tight End - A discussion on their options 1

As the draft nears a small wave of support for the Cowboys taking a tight end in the first round has grown. The top targets of interest at the position are Michael Mayer, Darnell Washington, and Dalton Kincaid.

But does spending a first-round pick — and the money that goes with it — on a tight end make sense?

Do the Cowboys even need to worry about the position to begin with? Frankly, no.

If Dallas was concerned about the players they have on the roster — Jake Ferguson and Peyton Hendershot — at the position, they wouldn’t have let Dalton Schultz go.

Especially when they could have re-signed him rather cheaply after his free agency market fizzled.

REPORT: Cowboys, Dalton Schultz Not Expected to Reach Contract Agreement

Put me in the camp that thinks there is no way the Cowboys take a tight end this early. But also don’t expect me to be shocked if they somehow go ahead and do so.

This is the Jones family we’re talking about.

But let’s take a look at the pros and cons of spending the 26th pick on Thursday evening on a tight end.

Is there a good reason why one of the three listed above should be on the Cowboys’ card?

How It Could Happen

If the skill players at running back and receiver fly off the board early — an unlikely scenario — Dallas would have a tough call to make.

Shore up their offensive or defensive lines, or take a tight end. They’d be tempted to give Dak Prescott another target to throw to.

Mayer is the top-ranked player at the position coming into the draft. He’s been nicknamed “Baby Gronk” and is projected to go mid-first round. He could slip back to the Cowboys depending on how other teams draft.

If the goal is to give Prescott another target — and Mayer is gone — Kincaid would be the logical next pick. As a receiver, he checks off all the boxes.

But his Achilles Heel is his blocking, especially in the run game.

Second half of McIntrye's mock draft has Cowboys drafting offense
Utah tight end Dalton Kincaid, left, runs after catching a pass as Colorado safety Jeremy Mack Jr. (3) pursues in the first half of an NCAA college football game Saturday, Nov. 26, 2022, in Boulder, Colo. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski)

So if the Cowboys are looking for a blocking tight end — which you can get in a later round — with the potential to become a threat in the passing game, you’re looking at Washington.

But, do you spend a first-round pick on a blocker?

Why It Makes No Sense

The Cowboys have two very good tight ends on the roster already. It isn’t a position of need. And there are options available later in the draft.

Taking Tucker Kraft out of South Dakota State in the third or fourth round would be the right play. He was a solid receiver for the Jackrabbits during their National Championship run last year. And he is a solid blocker.

There are a couple of other players who will be available in the middle rounds at the position, freeing Dallas up to address greater needs.

What Will Likely Happen

Sometime late Thursday evening, the Cowboys’ draft card will be handed to Roger Goodell.

He will walk up and announce the pick.

Roger Goodell

It will likely be Bryan Bresee, a defensive tackle from Clemson, or O’Cyrus Torrence, an offensive lineman from Florida. The longshots are: Bijan Robinson (running back, Texas) or Quentin Johnson (receiver, TCU).

But if Goodell says the words “tight end” at any point during Dallas’ pick, start reaching for the smelling salts.

I’m going to need as many as I can get to revive me.

Was this helpful?


Richard Paolinelli is an award-winning sports journalist with 34 years of professional newsroom experience. His newspaper career (1991–2011) includes the Gallup Independent, Modesto Bee, Gustine Press-Standard, Turlock Journal, Merced Sun-Star, Tracy Press, Patch, and San Francisco Examiner. He received the 2001 California Newspaper Publishers Association Best Sports Story award. Richard has authored two non-fiction sports books and 11 novels. At InsideTheStar.com, he has published 874 articles reaching over 728,000 readers.

17 Comments

  1. David A Nugent
    And it’s the best move that the Cowboys can make it look at what you’re getting If we bring in the best tight end in this draft, you get another guy on the offensive line and you get another player. They can catch the ball from Prescott. It’s the best move it’s the common sense move.
  2. Michael Fernandez
    Take the best player
  3. James Wiseman
    Rather a running back outta Alabama Gibbs
  4. Vernon (Jerry) Bell
    What if all of the best OTs, and DTs are gone then Dallas trades back to a high second round pick?
  5. john dixon
    All media hype. No way they take a TE before the 4th round. I do not even understand why the media and supposed analysts keep saying it. History with Dallas and MM shows they do not spend high picks on a TE. They take them around round 4 or later. If a top guy falls badly to the 3rd then maybe. Otherwise they are not doing it.
  6. Gary Seefeldt
    Don't do it ....... go o line cb even rb.
  7. Lawrence
    Hello Richard! I hope they'll get away from their normal screw-up pattern and just BE SMART for a change. The draft is an opportunity to get better and get deeper at certain positions. The Cowboys need Defensive Tackles, Guards, and I think Jack Campbell at Linebacker! Given the opportunity to play, Campbell would send Vander Esch to the bench and eventually out of Dallas. Parsons and Campbell could wreck havoc on offenses for years to come. Tight Ends we have! Ferguson and Hendershot can both play. I agree with you that another Tight End can be found later in the draft. I'm not saying Jack Campbell is a 1st rounder, just that he seems like a very good football player. Personally I'd like to see the team draft Robinson or Gibbs in the 1st round. If Pollard wasn't or isn't ready to start the season, both of those kids would be nice replacements.
    1. john dixon
      I think Gibbs is the best out of the two. They are even in most areas other than Gibbs has had about half the work load and taken half the beating.
      1. Lawrence
        John, it would be a big time win for Dallas if either one falls to the 26th spot and Jerry and Stephen Jones pulled the trigger on the deal.I think Gibbs has better foot speed, but Robinson, in my opinion , is the more complete back right now.
  8. Mario Leasure
    No it wouldn't it's literally the only position of need that wasn't addressed in free agency
  9. Allyson Nicole Thompson
    No it wouldn't
  10. Jerry J. Jones-aka Jesse
    We have Ferguson and Hendershot we’re good
    1. Steve Preciado
      Jerry J. Jones-aka Jesse EXACTLY!!! I don't understand all this attention for a TE at #26. Makes no sense when we have those other two that have dine great as rookies.
  11. Daniel Galindo
    Don't need one
  12. Douglas Paul
    TE talk is foolish when we have just Jags @ DT and No LG, but yeah keep Talking about shiny New TE's & WR's. We need a QB much more than another TE!
  13. Benjamin Brenner
    Cowboys don't need a tight end at 1 they have Jake Ferguson who broke out last year, that's a reason why they let Shultz walk I see them going Either O-Line or RB in round 1
    1. Shawn Lawther
      Benjamin Brenner or DT, the last thing we need is a tight end that would bump Ferguson from starting

Comments are closed.