Troy Aikman vs Tony Romo Stat Comparison

17
Troy Aikman vs Tony Romo: Stat Comparison

The Dallas Cowboys have always been known to have some great quarterbacks in their franchise, two examples of which are Troy Aikman and Tony Romo. These two quarterbacks are some of the most well-known players in NFL history, but which one has better stats?

The one and only Troy Aikman

Troy played 12 years in the NFL and all of them were with the Cowboys. He started in 165 games with a record of 94-71. With three Super Bowl wins, Troy was an icon for the Dallas Cowboys in the 1990s.

To observe some more detailed stats, we can see that Troy’s completion percentage was 61.5%. He threw for 165 touchdowns and 141 interceptions. He had a total of 32,942 yards in his career.

The six-time Pro Bowler also had a playoff record of 11-4. He holds a total of 15 comebacks and 20 game-winning drives.

Wow, Troy seems to be the man.

At this point, can Tony Romo even rival him in statistics?

The indelible Tony Romo

Tony Romo played 13 seasons in the league, though he did not play a game in the 2016 NFL regular season. His record is 78-49 in 156 games started. Tony sadly does not have any Super Bowl wins and has a playoff record of just 2-4.

His other stats consist of a passer rating of 65.3%. He had 248 touchdowns and only 117 interceptions. Romo had a total of 34,183 yards and four Pro Bowl appearances. Tony had 24 comebacks and 29 game-winning drives in his career.

Those are a whole lot of numbers for two different quarterbacks.

Now, we can see a big difference between the two.

Troy seems to have had better luck in the playoffs while Tony did not. This is always the main factor when comparing two players side by side with each other, especially quarterbacks. So, Troy takes the cake on that matter.

Upon further inspection, it seems that Tony Romo has better stats in some areas than Troy Aikman did. This can be proved in completion rate, touchdowns, interceptions, and total yards.

Tony even has a better record than Troy in the regular season.

Which player is better?

Even with better stats, Tony can’t compare when it comes to every NFL season’s main objective: winning the Super Bowl.

Troy succeeded in this matter while Romo didn’t come close in any of his attempts. Troy Aikman is the superior quarterback in this area and deserving of his high praise on the matter.

On the other hand, we can not leave out Tony Romo. This man still holds records and still has the ninth-highest passer rating in NFL history, which is just one spot behind Tom Brady. Tony has the better stats for sure, yet lacks in terms of playoff wins.

It’s really difficult to compare both of these amazing quarterbacks.

Each one has had amazing seasons and both had big impacts on the Dallas Cowboys. They are both super talented and each one is skilled in their own right.

Was this helpful?


Hey there! My name is Tony Stahl. I have two passions, writing, and football, when you put those two together you have where I am now, Inside the Star! I am 19 and live in Fort Worth and am a huge Cowboys fan. Football is my most favorite topic and I could talk your head off all day about it.

17 Comments

  1. T.A.Souza
    Troy had two great coaches back to back. Romo never had the coaches of the quality of Troy. Troy had a cast of great characters that played great where as Tony had a cast of characters who played the game well. Romo on Troy's team with Troy's coaches 2 would have won multiple Super Bowls and perhaps a few more.
  2. Charles Gaines
    They were both better than the one they have now and the only one that'may have them both beat is Tom Brady and he is over rated by a long shot he just has a line that keeps him safe and makes it looks as if he is better than anyone I think Romo took troy that's just me
  3. Kendall
    Tebow is one playoff victory away from matching the overrated qb and overrated announcer.
  4. Richard
    Completely different eras... different rules. Romo would be dead if he had taken the shots Aikman took REGULARLY.
    1. Charles Gaines
      I couldn't have said that better
    2. Tracy Willoughby
      Aikman all the way!
  5. Jorge
    No comparison. One won three rings and the other one won zilch. End of story!
    1. John
      Romo was a great QB just like Troy but let’s also compare the teams around both players, Troy would have the same number of rings as Romo if he had the teams and coaches that Romo had to play with. When Cowboys management even admits they wasted Romo’s talent that’s all we really need to know
      1. Kendall
        Bless your heart.
    2. Tony Stahl
      Avatar
      Yep, I agree. Although Romo seems to have better stats, there's no denying that Aikman is the superior player in this match-up.
      1. GhostProtocol
        David, simply put ... Romo doesn't put up the same stats he did if he played on Aikman's teams with that same staff. Aikman was not asked to put up numbers, while Romo's teams were completely dependent on him. Aikman brought more to the team and field than Romo from an intangibles perspective and was at least his equal from a skills perspective. It's a fun debate.
        1. Marvin Smith
          Man Aikman has almost as many interceptions as TD. Goes to show if he was put in that come from behind situation like Romo was all the time
      2. David
        The fact is Aikman played with superior teams - he wasn't close to being the superior qb. Romo never had close to the quality of offensive line, running back, receivers, or defense that Aikman played with, and he still put up comparable/better numbers. Fact: Dallas beats Buffalo in the '93 Superbowl (52-17); however loses first two games including loss Washington (16-35) and to Buffalo (10-13) in the 93' regular season; yet beats Buffalo '94 Superbowl (30-13). The difference no Emmitt Smith first two games of the '93 regular season. Put Tony on the same teams that Aikman had, and in my opinion they win more Superbowls.
      3. GhostProtocol
        But what if Romo had that exact same team? The main thing he didn't seem to have that Aikman did have was that x-factor.
    3. Bartman
      Jorge is the man! No Comparison what so ever. 3 of the greatest playoff chokes in history should also be added to the Romo list!
      1. Marvin Smith
        What 3 playoff chokes? I only remember him fumbling the fg attempt Aikman SB#2 200 yds 1TD Aikman SB#3 200 yds 1TD 1INT Now if that team wasn't a dynasty you think this performance would win the superbowl

Comments are closed.